As seen on Karen and Rudy:
Thanks to a behind the scenes image, I’ve been able really replicate these quite accurately. Print files below the jump!
I did tweak some of the alignment and spacing very slightly, and you are going to have to laminate these and then punch a slot in them, right at the top of the “A.” Additionally, I’m not sure exactly how big these are supposed to be, so that’s dependent on you and your laminating supplies. At 100%, they are 3.666 x 2.475 inches.
Print on white paper or cardstock, and trim at the trim marks.